WCB Building Envelope Retrofit
Winnipeg, Manitoba

The Workers Compensation Board Building after retrofit. The stainless steel “expansion joints” are visible on the east façade and at the base of the columns. Source: 1x1 Architecture Inc.
Designed by Smith, Carter, Searle and Associates, the building was originally commissioned for the Monarch Life Assurance Company and was constructed in 1961. This landmark building, a finalist for the Massey Medal for Architecture in 1964, was carefully designed to express the bold confidence and security of the corporation, its concern for its clients and employees, and its commitment to the economic development of the city of Winnipeg.
Building Description
As with many buildings from the mid-twentieth century, the exterior envelope and cladding system was failing and in need of repair due to deficiencies in the building envelope. A total of 4,044 granite stone panels were removed, repaired, and re-installed in their original location following asbestos abatement and the installation of a new high-performance building envelope system. This resulted in a +/-5” outward displacement of the stone cladding, creating a requirement for new stainless steel “expansion joints” that run the full height of the building in the granite façade.
Selected for its durability and flexibility, an aluminum composite panel was used on the main and sixth floor soffits in lieu of the original stucco. All 192 windows were replaced with new units which included a stainless steel mullion cap to match the original design.
New coping stones, supplied by Coldspring Granite in Minnesota (the original granite quarry that supplied the granite 50 years earlier), were installed around the entire roof to maintain the original detailing at the façade while providing a proper connection to the roof membrane.
The overall approach to the building envelope retrofit was to bring the façade back to its original designed state. This goal was achieved by “undoing” previous, less sensitive alterations, including carefully refining details because of the outward displacement of the building’s cladding system and remaining faithful to the longstanding material palette that was selected over fifty years ago. While many Modernist building façades are being carelessly manipulated due to maintenance issues, economic challenges, a passing design fancy, the restoration of the Workers Compensation Board respects this timeless symbol of a Modernist heritage building.
Related Inherently Sustainable Elements
Sustainability Challenges
- “Undoing” previous, insensitive alterations;
- Sourcing materials to match those originally installed;
- Re-installing the stone cladding with increased structural steel support to meet current National Building Code structural requirements;
- Working in the presence of designated;
- Not damaging the existing panels during construction.

Outward displacement of the exterior granite cladding required by the introduction of a new high performance building envelope. The image on the right illustrates the location of the stainless steel “expansion joints” Source: 1x1 Architecture Inc.
Key Strategies for Sustainable Rehabilitation
- Salvaging and re-installing existing granite cladding panels;
- Upgrading to a new high-performance building envelope;
- Installing new high performance windows;
- Maintaining and using a highly durable material palette;
- Ensuring the finished project respects the original design.
About the Case Study
Originally Constructed 1961
Rehabilitated 2013
Rehabilitation Team Members
- 1x1 Architecture Inc.
- Akman Construction Ltd.
- Alpha Masonry
- Crosier Kilgour and Partners Ltd.
- Smith Carter Architects
- SMS Engineering Ltd.
Original Uses
- Office
New Uses
- Office